Ah yes, Occam's razor.  The theory that the simplest explanation is=20
probably the right one.  Unfortunately, "simplest" usually means "the=20
one I'm most comfortable with".

Kerry


RussellMc wrote:
>> I see a lot of speculation on the net concerning the size of Napoleon
>> Solo's antenna.  I suppose it's all in fun,
>>    =20
>
> Surely not! ?
>
>  =20
>> ... but it really is easily
>> explained.  He only needs to be in range of a repeater.  There is no
>> reason to assume that his little radio is transmitting from Latvia to
>> DC, it only needs to reach the US embassy or consulate in Latvia, or the
>> embassy of a US ally, or a US ship at sea, or the repeater he left in
>> his hotel room, or even a US satellite.
>>    =20
>
> "it only needs to be" would perhaps better be "One explanation might
> be that it only needs to  ..."
> Which is true.
> But he uses the device so universally and so apparently randomly, that
> such an explanation seems unlikely.
> Hence my:
>
>  =20
>>  ...  As global
>>    =20
> range was available from all locations and as satellite or cellular
> networks or hackable networks to act as transport systems were all
> lacking during the devices' hey day it seems that HF is being utilised
> in some manner.
>  =20
>
> I posit that Occam would prefer an "early" implementation of a SPV
> system, easily enough discovered [tm] by those duly skilled in the
> art, with no super modern technology required, to the serendipitous
> ability to always be in range of some implausibly placed and available
> transit point.
>
> Unlike many other technologies, S.P.V. seems to require not too much
> more than pieces of suitably shaped metal plus some dieletrics and
> insulation - to yield inductors, capacitors & conductors as
> appropriate. Maxwell (and Poynting!) would have agreed that such a
> development was well overdue.
>
> The MIT paper is a clear smokescreen, written in 1948, in the era when
> the eager minds of Enigma, Trinity, Ultra, 382nd platoon, Bletchley,
> Tube metals, Manhattan Project and many more were being remelded into
> eg Operation Unthinkable (already by then very thinkable indeed),
> Universal exports, Gehlen organisation and their ilk.Half (about) the
> worlds finest brains were being turned to new pursuits as their past
> areas of expertise became redundant. The 1948 paper's "We've gone
> about as far as we can go" perspective is hardly what you'd
> realistically expect of the world conquering heros of MIT at that
> stage. Occam knows!
>
>  =20
>> Kerry
>>    =20
>
>  =20
>> RussellMc wrote:
>>    =20
>>> I was drivelling in a private email ...
>>>      =20
>
> See.
>
>
>            R
>
>  =20



--=20
Internal Virus Database is out-of-date.
Checked by AVG Anti-Virus.
Version: 7.0.289 / Virus Database: 267.11.13 - Release Date: 10/6/05

--=20
http://www.piclist.com PIC/SX FAQ & list archive
View/change your membership options at
http://mailman.mit.edu/mailman/listinfo/piclist
.