Russell McMahon wrote:
> We now have a wholly unmoderated list membership.

That's a step in the right direction.  However, we still have the threat of
moderation hanging over us for things many here consider trivial offenses or
no offense at all.

> We have  a chance to get on with things and conduct ourselves in an
> adult way - whatever that may mean to whoever.

Exactly.  It means very different things to different people.  Unfortunately
you have made it clear you will apply your particular view and deal harshly
with those that fall outside of it.

> The "newcomers" 'problem' is academic. Why don't we all just wait in
> eager anticipation of the first "problem' arriivng and see how
> maturely we can handle it between us.

While you hold the threat of moderation over the whole experiment.  That's
no experiment at all.

> No need for PC or wussy. Just sensible politeness.

PC, wussy, and sensible by who's interpretation.  Are you willing to allow
that others' interpretation of those vary considerably from yours?

> AND if the outcome leaves any seasoned members feeling like leaving in
> silence with banners flying they will presumably be mature enough to
> first discuss why with the list admins.

We *have* been discussing it.  So far you haven't budged at all.  You only
preach to us how your way is right.  In fact the new rules seem to be
tighter than they ever were.  You are killing this list.

-- 
http://www.piclist.com PIC/SX FAQ & list archive
View/change your membership options at
http://mailman.mit.edu/mailman/listinfo/piclist