Xiaofan Chen wrote:

>> Bob Blick wrote:
>>
>>> I've finally had enough of this crap. Have your pseuedo-scientific
>>> mumbo-jumbo and while you're at it, tie some magnets to the fuel line
>>> on your automobile to get better mileage, Russell.  It's you or me and
>>> I quit. You win. Have fun with what's left of the piclist.
>>
>> Now come on... This from the one who wants to keep [EE] "clean"?
> 
> Don't you think Bob Blick has a valid point? 

If he has one, he has taken very little effort to make it clear. I've
stated my opinion in various messages in this thread... 

First, I think he should have held this discussion in OT in the first
place. Producing all this chatter in EE while at the same time complaining
about a few posts with links to scientific sites in EE is... odd. 

Second, there were very few real arguments, about what specific post was or
wasn't about science or engineering, and why exactly. Just a general "I'm
tired of GW, so I don't want anybody to post about it in anything I read. I
don't read OT, so post it there. I myself however can pollute the EE space
with my own non-EE issues whenever I like". For me that's not what I call a
"valid point". He may have one besides this one, but I couldn't really
extract it from his posts.

Then there's 3rd and 4th and 5th and so on... I won't repeat it all :)

Gerhard

-- 
http://www.piclist.com PIC/SX FAQ & list archive
View/change your membership options at
http://mailman.mit.edu/mailman/listinfo/piclist