Byron has absolutely nailed this one in my opinion, based on the people I know. The painful conclusion I have reached is that most parents do not actually want kids. They want "a nice car and house with picket fence and 2.3 kids" they don't ACTUALLY want kids. I didn't actually want kids, but I find they have grown on me. And I couldn't stand to do to them what my parents did to me... put me in public school, ignore my reports of the torture the bullies and teachers put me through and ignore the fact that I learned more on my own, at home, than I did in school. I mean, if a kid loves to read, all you have to do is put the right books in front of 'em and you pretty much have it in the can. I asked to be in boy scouts. Nope. I asked for martial arts classes. Nope. I asked them to let me ride my bike the 4 miles to the public library in our very safe country "town". Nope. I got a dog (because the deer would eat my Moms garden without one). And I got a stereo (because my dad got a better one and didn't want to pay to dispose of the old (huge) speakers). The school library was pretty much my life line. That and access to cast off parts and tools from my dads shop and components I salvaged from dead appliances around the area. They did buy me a computer one year (COSMIC ELF) and dad did spend time answering my questions. He also beat the crap out of me with his thin black belt if I pissed him off. I mean welts on my back, ass and legs. That's who I am. Now I yell at my kids when they piss me off, but I don't beat them (or spank or box their ears or any other euphemisms used for physical injury) and I do pay for them to join the clubs and take the classes they want. And they don't know what a bully is. They know how to resolve conflicts by confronting, explaining how they feel, and then contacting an authority figure if necessary. Like mature adults, rather than "lords of the flies." They watch discovery, history and science channel. They have the internet (in the living room with us watching) and they have a mother with an MSW and a father who always answers their questions as best I can. Hopefully they won't even yell at their kids. -- James. -----Original Message----- From: piclist-bounces@mit.edu [mailto:piclist-bounces@mit.edu] On Behalf Of Byron Jeff Sent: Saturday, March 22, 2008 16:20 To: Microcontroller discussion list - Public. Subject: Re: [OT] Who is to blame: Was:Usingvoucherstoimprovethequalityofschools(was:Educationreform) What doesn't happen is parental discipline. And no matter what you do inside the school walls, if the parents do no discipline, then nothing good ever happens. See that's the missing element from the equation. Students haven't changed much over the years. What has changed is the parental involvement and discipline. Some children disrespect their parents, and as an extension disrespect authorities at school. There are many more screw-ups that are parents now than ever before. -- http://www.piclist.com PIC/SX FAQ & list archive View/change your membership options at http://mailman.mit.edu/mailman/listinfo/piclist