Herbert Graf wrote:
>
> > And every MP3 player I've tried in the last month requires
> > that it's OWN driver be loaded. None seem to support the generic
> > 'storage' device type (e.g. Yepp, IRiver, WaveX, Rio...).
>         You have to blame the RIAA for that. It's their insistence on "protecting"
> their IP that results in stupid and hacked implementations like what you're
> seeing.

That actually makes sense. There had to be some good reason that
MP3 players are so stupidly implemented.

I also recently read where the linux geeks had figured out
the protocol for Sony MD players, but discovered that the
data packets are all encrypted so they can't use it as a
portable storage device.

> > The Yepp wasn't cheap, and it came from a supposedly reputable
> > company. It went back untested.
>
>         Blame the RIAA for forcing the companies to come up with "secure" ways of
> doing things, ways that go beyond the spirit of the technologies used.

How long before our hard drives are forced to NOT store MP3's
that are not officially sanctioned?

> > I don't know of many PIC applications that need the 400mbs pipe
> > firewire gives, but it looks to be LOT easier to code for.
>
>         And that's my point. With firewire you either have all or nothing, you
> CAN'T do firewire cheap and slow. Why? It was NEVER meant for that, USB is.

Yes, I agree with that. Unfortunately, from my jaded perspective
USB is still complex compared to a 'legacy' port.

> > Any idea where to get those 'micro USB' PCB connectors,
> > suitable drivers/chips, PIC code and my life back?
>
>         After the tone and way you have treated my opinion I hope you don't expect
> help from me, but for the record: you won't be receiving any.

Thank you for the offer.
I meant no disrespect. I'm just very frustrated with my recent
bad USB experiences. I'm sure there is good money to be made by
a USB-PIC experienced engineer.

It's been a most enlightening thread. Thanks again to all
who contributed.

Robert

--
http://www.piclist.com#nomail Going offline? Don't AutoReply us!
email listserv@mitvma.mit.edu with SET PICList DIGEST in the body