I know that many of you have the book, The Art of Electronics, this question deals with the circuit from fig 2.75 on page 105. a zener diode and two transistors, along with 3 1K resistors. I thought I would try to make this circuit, but I couldn't get the exact components, and I thought great, this will be a learning experience, LOL this is pretty stupid, but maybe some of you will help out Q1 - 2N3055 Q2 - 2N3904 D1 - 1N4731 4.3V R1,2,3 1K I substituted a TIP3055 for the Q1 2N3055 are these even close? a MPS3904 for the Q2 2N3904 ?? and a 1N4733 5.1V for the 1N4731 4.3V my input voltage is 15vdc and I get 5.5vdc output what I'm really wanting to know is, what is the most important component for determining the output? is it the diode? if so, why? I rekon if these transistors are just variations of the ones called for in this circuit, then the resistors are the same, the diode must be the deciding factor? but the circuit claims to regulate 12 to 25 v input to 10 v output, so my 5.5v out is way off from this, so does a difference of a 5.1V zener versus a 4.3V zener make this much of a difference? thanks -- http://www.piclist.com#nomail Going offline? Don't AutoReply us! email listserv@mitvma.mit.edu with SET PICList DIGEST in the body