> On some other fora I see arguments pro and con pulsing of a LED
> to achieve better (perceived?) brightness with the same average
> current. Does anyone know of hard (experimental) data about this?

Quotes from previous discussions - seems very subjective

===================================================

one of the threads in that hazily-recalled discussion was
persistence of vision and whether pulse width / frequency could be
optimised to take best advantage of it. Although brightness of LEDs
can be measured empirically, persistence of vision from person to
person is subjective, leading one to set up for "average" intensities
that are acceptable to as wide a range of viewers as possible

===============================================

Pulsed light is claimed to have a greater apparent brightness for the
same average energy. I guess the human eye acts as a peak detector.

===============================================

Much closer to an average detector. The apparent brightness only
changes slightly (usually improves) with shorter duty cycles and the same
average current. Losses increase, of course, as Vf increases.
With early (1970's) LED materials, there was a threshold of perhaps
1mA below which not much light was emitted, but with modern materials
it is much more zero-based. Super-bright GaAlAs LEDs are usable and
fairly linear over a very wide range, from 10's of microamps to scores
of mA.

It's easy to test this, all you need is a scope and a source of
square waves of different duty cycles (I'd expect you to use a PIC,
of course). You can scope the voltage across the dropping resistor to
see what the actual current and duty cycle is. Pick a couple of
matched LEDs and adjust them for equal brightness with different
duty cycles.

If the pulses are slow enough that the flicker is visible, then the
results will be different, favoring the short duty cycles if they
are long enough.

There are also some interesting shifts in the spectrum of the
emitted light with current, some of the effect due to heating of
the die, and some not

--
http://www.piclist.com hint: PICList Posts must start with ONE topic:
[PIC]:,[SX]:,[AVR]: ->uP ONLY! [EE]:,[OT]: ->Other [BUY]:,[AD]: ->Ads