>Brandon has a circuit just about ready to go to PCB >http://groups.yahoo.com/group/cump/files/CUMP%28A%29/MB_0.2.0.PNG >and I'm starting to write the byte code interpreter >http://www.piclist.com/cump/bytecode > >James Newton: PICList.com webmaster, former Admin #3 I've been sitting here on the side of the discussion hoping at some point I can jump in and contribute something (anything). I've read three messages that seem to make the best points and all more or less agree with each other. One was a post Olin made about having an absolute newbies pic guide, someone else questioning if we needed "YAPP" and now James mentioning a few more details about cump. I think one of the biggest problems someone faces getting started with pics is not that there is a lack of information but a rather overwhelming amount of it. I think(know) a lot of people will grab 84's for a few very simple reasons. One is they can buy them off the shelf. I live in a town of about 150K size and the one place had 5 84a's just because he ordered them in himself to play with and didn't use them. In my case I would have liked to have used another one like the 628 but I couldn't get them locally or quickly, I had no idea what programmer etc would work or existed for it. (ok I actually bought 84' to drive Brendon's bp up a bit ;-]) Here the thing I searched the pic achieves and read all the programmer stuff, I printed out several schematics only to find I would be stuck using just this pic or that one. In other words spending money and time and as other have pointed out outgrowing the thing and starting all over again. I'd rather build one than buy one but I'm sure others would want it assembled and tested. I'm sure a few guys can chirp up with what percentage of sales are kit or assembled programmers. The more I read the threads, and see the ideas develop my concern is that all the effort is going to be wasted as the new guys won't be able to know what to look for or what they are looking at. Ie I still wonder just what the #$% a boot loader is ;-] Olin more or less blurted out, that someone (actually finger was pointed at me) to write a faq. I'd be willing to work on it with some help from some of the people who know a bit more about the hardware and software than I do. I think there needs to be a document that a new person can look at what to start off with pic, programmer wise. I'm sure there are enough existing options out there right now that the average person could build or buy and not get stuck if they knew where or what. I'm tied up with patent lawyers right now bt I'd like to take a crack at doing a faq from a complete newbies aspect. Sort of a non technical first steps guide. If you don't think this is worth doing, I'd ask you to think back when the last time someone asked "what programer" or "this one didn't work", you might have to go back a week on the list. If that same person can look at a chart that guides them into starting off with something they can actually use you might find a few more people not having to ask. Anyway thats the idea. "Is it worth doing? -- http://www.piclist.com hint: PICList Posts must start with ONE topic: [PIC]:,[SX]:,[AVR]: ->uP ONLY! [EE]:,[OT]: ->Other [BUY]:,[AD]: ->Ads