> >> I don't understand what the argument is here. Seems to me a >> 2D-R --> pin protection ckt is perfectly correct, as long as R >> is chosen to limit the max current into the clamping diodes on >> the pin to a safe value. Chose R > 20 ohms [0.6v/0.025A], and >> go. You will "never" actually see Vcc+0.6v on the pin, due to >> the IR drop. > >The issue in this thread is that the pin is specced for 0.3v above Vdd, and >before the internal clamping diodes 'kick in' you can have more than 0.3v. > Just make sure to have a series R right at the pin. ============= >> I have a more interesting question, however. >> >> Say you use the 2D but no R. And say you overvoltage it, and >> run too much current thru the internal diodes, and blow them. >> Well, you still have the external diodes there, and seems they >> will forthwith protect the chip from the stresses the built-in >> diodes where in there for in the first place - ESD. And they >> will certainly be much more robust than the internal diodes. >> >> No ????????/ [any takers?] >> Too bad - no takers. - dan ============= -- http://www.piclist.com hint: The list server can filter out subtopics (like ads or off topics) for you. See http://www.piclist.com/#topics